Most Americans can agree the Adrian Peterson crossed the line as soon as he whipped his four-year-old son with a switch and left cuts and welts on the boy’s legs. But the line for what constitutes illegal habits when it involves parents highlight their children is subject to different rules transparent the country.

You are watching: Is it illegal for a girl to hit a boy

Peterson appears to have actually genuinely believed at the that he was not abusing his son. After all, the is legal come hit a child in all fifty U.S. States and also the ar of Columbia. States differ widely around what specifically is allowed.

In Delaware, for example, state legislation forbids a parental from hitting a boy with a closed fist. Yet in Oklahoma, no together explicit ban exists. There, the legislation permits a parental to hit a boy with a switch listed that the parent only uses “ordinary force.”

Much depends on the discretion that prosecutors. Both Arizona and Alabama permit the use of “reasonable and appropriate physical force,” but what is “reasonable and appropriate” in every state relies on existing situation law and also the interpretation of judges. The truth that Louisiana renders no cite of spanking but enables “reasonable discipline” that doesn’t “seriously endanger” the health of a child.

“It’s a very complicated subject,” manager of the American Bar Association’s center on Children and the law Howard Davidson called “I personally favor parents discovering what the law says in terms of what they can and can’t do and also just speak ‘reasonable’ doesn’t administer a the majority of guidance,” he said.

In Texas, corporal penalty becomes child abuse when it “results in comprehensive harm come a child.” together a handy matter in Texas, that way a physical injury that leaves a mark, favor bleeding and also bruising, together Peterson reportedly did.

The regulation in that state is clearer than some others around when a spanking becomes child abuse. The standard—when a swat leaves a mark—is common amongst many states however what specifically a “mark” is doesn’t always mean the same thing. In Maine, for instance, corporal punishment is lawful if it outcomes “in no an ext than transient uncomfortable or minor short-term marks.” Georgia simply forbids any type of “physical injury,” however here again, what that method is largely at the discretion of judges and also prosecutors.

Some, choose Deb Sandek, routine director with the facility for efficient Discipline, argue, no without evidence, that corporal punishment of any kind causes psychological trauma in children and also should be banned entirely. “There are effective technique strategies that teach children right from wrong,” she said. “Why not go in a an ext proactive strategy and assist children learn to trouble solve and also handle problem without aggression?”

Around the people 39 countries, including Malta, Bolivia, and Brazil this year, have actually banned corporal punishment of children.

See more: Daisy Red Ryder Bb Gun Repair /Rehab, Daisy Red Ryder Fix

But any type of such national ban would certainly go against the serial of publicly opinion today: 4 out of 5 Americans believe spanking children is somebetterworld2016.orgs appropriate, follow to a 2013 poll from the Nielsen-owned sector research for sure Harris Interactive. Prevent a major shift in public opinion or justice interpretation, ~ above corporal punishment of children we’ll it is in grappling v the devil in the details for some yet.