from the newspaper

when High colleges Shaped America’s Destiny

an early-twentieth-century grassroots movement for mass an additional education positioned the country for human being leadership.
that was, the Life magazine story began, “the frantic portion of the morning as soon as 2,003 boys and girls swarm about the Davenport High School and funnel themselves within to it is in exposed to what eager adults who await lock term secondary education.” The story, “U.S. Public High School,” showed up in the magazine’s December 14, 1953, issue, the inaugural short article in a series on the American high school—then, together now, a topic of concern—and it had chosen Davenport to stand for what had come to be the most characteristic of these institutions: the considerable high school, whereby students can study the traditional liberal art curriculum but additionally make usage of nonacademic offerings ranging from vocational training to commercial and business courses. “The college student still get classics,” Life wrote, “but their courses are no longer confined come subjects provided mainly for those going come college. . . . Right into Davenport High each day come student with various backgrounds, racial, religious and economic, each v his own difficulty of exactly how to fit right into a an altering society and also each v his very own prospects and also aspirations because that the future.”

Davenport High exemplified the comprehensive high school, beginning with that size. (Two the its quiet study-hall periods accommodated 389 student each.) It readily available classes in 127 subjects, “from algebra to zoology,” and also while students had to take some English, math, science, and history, lock could, v electives, research a broad range of noncollege-track material. Two student report cards depicted the range of options. A senior, Lon Fagner, who hoped to examine dentistry in ~ Northwestern University, was acquisition Grammar, American Government, Algebra III, Chemistry I, and Phys. Ed. A sophomore, James M. Jones, took English I, biological I, electrical energy I, maker Shop I, Phys. Ed., and Occupations, a compelled course that included vocational testing. Life’s well-illustrated story—the opening shot, reflecting a group of adolescents moving toward Davenport High’s big sandstone structure, would certainly resonate through anyone who ever before attended a huge or midsize American windy high school—pictured students functioning on whatever from advanced mathematics and science labs come music and dressmaking. A senior, Carol Jasper, stood on a workdesk while her fellow students checked her hemline. The young woman, hoping to uncover office occupational when she graduated, want to learn how to make few of her own garments to conserve money.

You are watching: How did american high schools change in the 1920s

None the this would strike contemporary readers together new, however in 1953, just a small portion of the grandparents of these Davenport students would certainly have had actually anything prefer this kind of schooling. Before the at an early stage twentieth century, couple of Americans had been educated past the eighth grade; the exact same was true in various other countries. The ambitious attempt to supply mass second education has become known together the American high school movement, and “American” that surely was—from its autonomous underpinnings and also grass-roots company to that is inspiring, however sobering, legacy. The movement assisted propel the United says into people leadership, yet the school of the high college would reflect an essential conflicts the have characterized American education ever since.

Only a country founded on ethics of equality and also self-government would have contemplated mass secondary education—and only then, after having mastered massive primary and also elementary education, at which the United says had also blazed a path, v the typical school motion of the nineteenth century, i beg your pardon itself had actually roots dating earlier to the nation’s founding. “Our education thinkers in the eighteenth and also nineteenth centuries observed the schools as the central and key hope for the conservation of autonomous ideals and the endurance the the nation as a republic,” writes education and learning scholar E. D. Hirsch. Castle “consistently alluded come the truth that republics have been among the least stable forms of government and also were always collapsing indigenous their internal antagonisms and self-seeking citizens.” In Massachusetts, Horace Mann, who would end up being known as the dad of the typical School, worked tirelessly to boost schools, which need to be, that urged, nonsectarian, open to all, and also guided by the principles of a cost-free society. Through the mid-1800s, typical schools had actually proliferated so commonly that American enrollment levels eclipsed those the Germany; by so late in the nineteenth century, the U.S. Had taken the worldwide lead in elementary education. European countries didn’t capture up until the rotate of the twentieth century.

By then, the United claims was poised because that a brand-new transformation. Economic changes during the last two decades of the nineteenth century made clear the a better-educated workforce was now necessary. Many Americans had traditionally worked in work that required tiny schooling. As late as 1870, according to Harvard economist Claudia Goldin, “only about 10 percent the the labor pressure were to work in an occupation that generally required one education beyond the elementary institution years, whereas the other 90 percent were employed in jobs that did not.” Fifty year later, in 1920, an ext than 25 percent of American workers organized jobs that forced a high school diploma or college degree.



Factors control the need for an ext educated workers contained increasing usage of office technologies, indigenous typewriters to including machines; the development of large, complex corporate entities, with offices in lot of cities; and also the growth of industries—including banking, insurance, and also retail but additionally manufacturing—that sought employee with an ext schooling. As at an early stage as 1902, a manager that the Deere Tractor agency specified that prospective masculine office hires need to be “at the very least high college graduates.” The preference was no confined come white-collar positions, though. “In the factory, we choose the guys to have actually a high school education and learning if possible,” claimed the hiring director at national Cash it is registered that very same year. The demand for professionals—doctors, lawyers, teachers, and also business managers—was additionally bursting. These job categories thrived 50 percent quicker than all other employment teams from 1870 to 1920.

Only a country founded on values of equality and also self-government would have actually contemplated mass secondary education.

Secondary schools had been around for about as lengthy as the usual schools, yet only a little proportion the American adolescents attended them. Most big cities had public high schools; yet in less populated areas, families seeking secondary education because that their youngsters paid tuition at personal academies. Now, passionate to satisfy the challenges of a new economy, the united States gone into uncharted waters, building public high schools and enrolling students on a fixed scale, through a goal of prepare the arising generation not simply academically but also vocationally for the adult world. With this brand-new practical focus, the American high school movement was born.

Scholars generally day the movement from 1910 come 1940, since these room the years once the greatest growth took place, both in opening high schools and in enrolling students. The impetus and also the execution come from regional communities, not from federal, or even state, government. Goldin’s substantial scholarship reveals that even significant statutes, favor compulsory-schooling and also child-labor laws, had tiny impact on how things developed. An ext than anything else, it was the unified States’ decentralized structure—with some 125,000 self-governing institution districts, in contrast with europe’s centrally run educational system—that play the an important role. If enough support exist in a community to progressive the taxes crucial to build a big (or small) public high school, up went the school. The colleges proliferated rapidly, in the old American can-do way—from 7,200 windy high schools in 1903 come 10,213 in 1910 come 14,326 in 1920.

One that those institutions was main High in St. Paul, the oldest continuously operation high school in Minnesota. Indigenous 1902 to 1955, central High graduated 11 Rhodes Scholars, much more than any school in America. Central had opened with just two students, one boy and also one girl, in 1870. Its first diplomas to be hand-printed top top sheepskin. Its contemporary building was set up in 1912, after enrollment pushed previous 1,300. A history of St. Paul, released that year, defined the new high school:

This school, currently completed and occupied, besides being an especially handsome structure, is sanitary, fireproof, light and also convenient. In enhancement to the twenty-six recitation rooms, and also ample lecture rooms and laboratories, it has an auditorium with a balcony, and with a phase 22 by 57 feet. It has actually dressing, scenery and property rooms; a huge gymnasium v shower and also dressing rooms; a students’ having lunch room through kitchen and pantry, and also all way of rooms because that domestic and also manual training, consisting of kitchen and also dining rooms, sewing room, machine shop, forge room and foundry. It . . . Is a building of which no the college board alone, but the whole city might well it is in proud.

Student Alice brief described the institution cafeteria’s industrial-size accommodations: “On that is hungriest day, 30 dozen bun sandwiches, 30 dozen lump of bread made into sandwiches, 30 dozen cup cakes, next to apples, sweet chocolate, doughnuts, ice cream cones and other things in proportion disappeared before the hungry group in 10 minutes.” demand was so an excellent that Central’s basic was increased in 1924; by 1936, central swelled v 2,900 students.

The story to be the very same elsewhere. Philadelphia’s main High school relocated come a brand-new building in 1900 as class sizes swelled. Grand Rapids, Michigan, opened up its main High institution in 1910. Through 1915, it was crammed with more than 1,800 students; come accommodate demand, the city established an additional comprehensive school, southern High School. Enrollment in the city’s high schools enhanced 160 percent between 1910 and also 1920.

These numbers reflected national trends. High school enrollment in the United says doubled in between 1900 and also 1910; that quadrupled in between 1900 and also 1920, when more than 2 million American teenagers were enrolled. The numbers kept rising, so the by 1940, there were about 6.6 million high college students in the joined States. The mushrooming enrollments reflect a larger and larger proportion of American teenagers. In 1910, less than 10 percent that American 18-year-olds i graduated from high school, and also only 19 percent of 15-to-18-year-olds were enrolled. By 1940, the day usually designated as the end of the high school movement, 51 percent the 18-year-olds graduated from high school, and virtually three-quarters that 15-to-18-year-olds to be attending. (Not surprisingly, provided segregation and racial discrimination, enrollment prices for blacks lagged much behind those because that whites.)

As v the common school movement, the leader at the outset were found in brand-new England; the laggards were in the South. Quickly pacesetters appeared in other places, such together the Midwest. By 1928, enrollment rates in new York and brand-new Jersey were just half those the Nebraska and Iowa. The sterling power of these breadbasket says led Goldin come a detect reminiscent of Robert Putnam’s insights about diversity and community cohesion: high college enrollments were highest in the most homogeneous communities, with shared values and common ambitions. The smallest communities had the highest rates of all. (In 1920, 50 percent of american still live in small towns.) The tiniest hamlet had tendency to have actually a greater proportion the high school enrollment than tiny towns; tiny towns had higher enrollments than tiny cities; small cities higher than midsize cities; and also midsize cities higher than large cities like brand-new York, Chicago, or Philadelphia. In gross, the huge cities enrolled the many high college students, however their proportions lagged in part because of greater work methods for teenagers.

If the high college movement’s appeal deserve to be found in broadening enrollments, that success deserve to be glimpsed in a statistic that, to modern-day eyes, might show up discouraging: the decreasing proportion the graduates that went on come college. As soon as the high institution movement obtained under way, roughly half of graduates went on to some kind of postsecondary education. Goldin discovered that, as the high college graduation price climbed, crossing end 50 percent through 1940, the proportion of graduates that pursued greater education decreased by half—even if, in gun numbers, much more students to be pursuing college than ever before. This numbers imply that the economic value that a high school diploma to be such that graduates did no feel the need to pursue college. Even low-level white-collar occupational paid, top top average, twice what employees earned in occupations the didn’t require high school diplomas.

Mass secondary education pushed the United states from toughness to strength: with the greatest standard of living and best-educated population in the world, Americans found themselves unique qualified for the leadership duty that they would certainly assume after civilization War II. Return veterans, many currently holding high school diplomas, would take advantage of the GI Bill, helping to begin what Goldin phone call America’s third education revolution, after ~ the common school and high institution movements: mass university attainment. “Americans were keenly aware that they were affiliated in an historic success and knew, as well, the they were setting the United says on a food far different from the being followed elsewhere in the world,” Goldin writes. “They were embarking on an experiment as cool as any kind of in American history.”

After much success, the experiment would at some point abandon the aspirations that launched it. The seeds of the abandonment to be planted early. In 1912, The Saturday Evening post published an short article by wilhelm Mearns, who taught creative writing at teachers College: “Our medieval High Schools: Shall us Educate children for the Twelfth or the twentieth Century?” Mearns attacked the timeless high college curriculum—English, classic literature, advanced mathematics, history—and asked even if it is such material had any relevance for the vast bulk of high college kids. The belittled the timeless course the study and asked what good it to be if a high institution student can not “pound warm bolts, or stoke a stationary engine, or tie increase a decent package.” High school education, that wrote, should be committed to “individual requirements and an attempt to fit the individual for what the ideal wisdom that the minute considers his welfare.”

Mearns had his finger top top the pulse that what modern-day educators, particularly progressives, believed: that most of the new students streaming right into the high schools—especially youngsters from immigrant families—were less intelligent than the typical student and also thus unsuited because that the scholastic curriculum. Numerous of this students would quite be working, anyway, than in school, progressives reasoned. Shouldn’t the high schools offer them other that would prepare lock for valuable work, fairly than filling your heads v Shakespeare? The schools should vastly increase their offerings the nontraditional, vocational, and commercial courses.

The progressives, Diane Ravitch created in her 2000 education history, Left Back, wanted to take it “a grim pruning hook come the dead limbs of tradition.” They argued that the modern-day high school should reject the “elitist” academic curriculum, left over from the nineteenth-century predecessor, which had been designed mainly for the college-bound. (In fact, previously high institutions were much from specifically college-prep institutions, yet the mischaracterization proved useful for the reformers.) In their decision to fit children from working-class and immigrant dwellings to what one educator called their “probable destinies,” the progressives collection themselves versus the supposedly antidemocratic defenders of classic courses, who said that, for as lengthy as children remained in school, they need to have accessibility to a traditional academic curriculum. Somehow, the progressives flourished in spreading themselves as advocates of democracy and also equal opportunity, also as they driven for differential therapy of students, depending on perceived aptitudes and also intelligence. As they witnessed it, your mission was to give kids the cultivate they required for their self-evident future functions in life.

Battles between reformers and also traditionalists to be hard-fought, through the reformers mostly prevailing—at least, in your goal of widening the curriculum to encompass nonacademic subjects. In the beforehand going, this greatly meant adding commercial courses such as typing, bookkeeping, and also stenography, and vocational topics such together electricity, metals, and also woodworking. Another area that broadened greatly was house economics. The push to open up up the curriculum took ar at the same time the public high schools were proliferating roughly the country. As a result, the an extensive high institution took ~ above the shape acquainted to us today. In its early incarnation, it to be highly effective at its goal of training adolescents for success in the adult world—in no small component because, while the reformers had actually succeeded in expanding course offerings, lock were much less effective, up to about 1930, in their second goal: deemphasizing the timeless curriculum the English, math, science, and history. Many students ongoing to take these classes, follow to considerable research by David L. Angus and also Jeffrey Mirel. Regardless of progressives’ warnings that the timeless curriculum was keeping less lean students away from high school and also sending them right into the workforce, enrollments retained rising.

The great Depression submarine the schools with still more new students. With tasks scarce, adults increasingly wanted teenagers out of the job market and also in school—no issue what they go there. In what had by now end up being a generational refrain, educators worried that the incoming student were less intellectually able 보다 their predecessors; as proof, they cited IQ scores, though some studies indicate that the intelligence-test outcomes contradicted their claims. Whereas previously reformers had actually sought mainly to slot students into either academic or vocational/commercial process of study, reformers in the great Depression, war, and postwar years progressively came to believe that many students weren’t qualified of success in either of these tracks.

It is at this point, Angus and also Mirel write, that educators began reconfiguring the high school more drastically. Lock assigned an ext students come the basic track, wherein they could get appropriate instruction in occurring “life-skills” the addressed their immediate needs, under to the many trivial topics, together as just how to act on dates. The National education and learning Association’s room of an additional School Principals claimed that timeless courses have to be replaced with “fundamental categories of genuine student experiences.” Harvard president James B. Conant said that parents have to accept educators’ judgments regarding the best future for their intellectually limited kids. The American high school started to change, note Angus and Mirel, from “an school that all set young civilization academically and vocationally for the adult world” come a “custodial” institution, more committed to social management and also conformity.

In its at an early stage incarnation, the substantial high school was highly reliable in training teens for success.

The pundit barrenness the resulted was a direct product the progressives’ dim check out of most young people’s psychological capacities and also future prospects. In Minneapolis, wherein high school enrollments prospered by virtually a third between 1930 and also 1934, college officials draft a freshman class, community Life Problems, that took student on field trips to government agencies and also businesses. In lieu that economics and American government, seniors took contemporary Problems, which concentrated on problems such together “population, labor, housing, family life, and consumer needs.” together Ravitch chronicled in Left Back, Denver’s hand-operated Training High School developed a two-hour everyday program top top “common problems of youth,” in i m sorry the students began by “getting to recognize the school; castle then moved onto difficulties of health, appearance, conduct, and `friendly adjustment come others.’ ” an Evanston, Illinois, high school changed its classic curriculum through a routine in “community living.” that is ten-point list of themes, with deadening language therefore characteristic of the self-control known as “social studies,” appeared designed to narcotize students right into apathy: “1. Understanding the neighborhood Setting; 2. Protecting Life and Health; 3. Do a Home; 4. Obtaining a Living; 5. Expressing spiritual Impulses; 6. Solve the Desire because that Beauty; 7. Securing an Education; 8. Cooperating in Social and also Civic Action; 9. Engaging in Recreation; 10. Boosting Material Conditions.” Postwar, these and also related approaches became known together “life-adjustment” education.

By the time Life’s 1953 Davenport story appeared, nationwide voices had actually been increased for years against the watering-down of curricular content. “The best education for the finest is the best education because that all,” claimed Robert Maynard Hutchins, who, along with others—Arthur Bestor, Isaac Kandel, Mortimer Adler, william Bagley—railed against the anti-intellectual curricular trends. A 1946 Detroit free Press collection concluded that high schools were failing to prepare young human being for the world because they had actually gone too far in replacing the traditional curriculum through “socialized” education. In 1958, the free Press did one more series, v even much more damning findings. The file found the college-track high school students were acquisition barely more academic courses than general-track student of a generation earlier. Nine out of ten high institution graduates failure exams for entry-level civil-service work in Detroit’s Wayne County. And also hiring managers at significant firms said the document that they didn’t put lot stock in high school diplomas any more, due to the fact that the schools had actually degraded requirements so severely. That observation made a stinging contrast with the desire of the national Cash register manager of a half-century earlier—“We prefer the guys to have a high school education if possible”—as walk the title of the cost-free Press’s series: “What is a high college diploma worth?”

These objections took ar when America still hosted a world-beating command in secondary-education attainment. Together late together the mid-1950s, by Goldin’s reckoning, the United says was 35 year ahead the the united kingdom on this metric. However the results of eroding requirements (at all levels) would quickly be felt. American 12th-graders’ reading scores “have never come earlier from their high point around 1950,” follow to E. D. Hirsch. In the more than half-century since then, students, parents, educators, and also public officials have waged battles over curriculum and also standards, over failing schools and also school choice, and also over the time-honored concern of what purpose high schools need to predominantly serve. The ambitious undertaking that introduced all this debates—the America high college movement—faded right into memory.

Taken every in all, the high school movement was an unprecedented effort by a huge country with a diverse population to meet the difficulties of a new economy. That flaws to be of a distinctively American character. The American commitment come democracy and also opportunity it is provided the movement however made it easier for progressives to case the mantle of equality in attacking “elitist” support for solid standards and rich curricula. The American passion for practicality, a disposition tracing earlier to the Mayflower, strengthened the high schools’ vocational content and helped create the workers the economy needed, yet it likewise made the institutions increasingly delicate to a short-term view of education, whether dismissing the value of traditional academics or embracing vapid collectivist trends favor “life adjustment.” and the local-authority orientation of American education, so crucial to launching the high school movement, looked much less like an unambiguous benefit after the 1950s, once other emerged nations finally started catching up through the U.S. On an additional education, and also eventually—in part because of their strict standards—leaving the U.S. Behind on global measures.

Though analogies come today space inexact, the American high school movement does market some crucial lessons. The an initial is a reminder that the fundamental importance of rigorous scholastic standards for all students—a principle championed by curriculum-reform teams like core Knowledge and also charter institution networks, such as great Hearts Academies and BASIS Charter Schools, amongst others. The high school motion in the heyday operated well because, also as considerable portions that students gotten in vocational tracks, they to be still largely gaining core academic instruction. When that changed, the outcomes suffered. The two techniques need not be separated—and traditional-curriculum proponents say so, too. “I’m a vast fan the high-quality liberal-arts education and learning for everybody and really perform think it would certainly go far to prepare far better citizens, neighbors, and also consumer/transmitters the America’s cultural heritage and also democratic underpinnings,” wrote education historian Chester Finn in 2012. “That said, I’m also becoming persuaded that the future of our economy and also the acquisition of good jobs will hinge as much on well-developed technological prowess as on Aristotle, Shakespeare, Darwin, Rembrandt, and also Mozart.”

Today’s brand-new model of vocational education and learning has integrated this holistic outlook: the best vocational-ed schools have reinstated academic standards, concentrating on core expertise in language and math. In part places, vocational-ed students space outperforming college student in timeless high schools. (See “Vocational Ed, Reborn.”) The adjust stems greatly from employers, who have actually made clear the they require job candidates who have the right to read, write, think—and it is adapted to change. This echoes the start of the high college movement, i m sorry was likewise driven through employers’ needs for smarter, trickster workers. As was true 100 years ago, a core scholastic curriculum is no an problem to this goal however integral to it.

Second, attempts to phase out traditional, rigorous academics for “real-world” curricula—whether the “life-adjustment” cultivate of the 1940s and also 1950s or, say, social-justice indict today—have never readily available anything the lasting value, and also they plunder students of priceless time that could be invested on structure skills. Together was true a century ago, schools need to stick mainly to schooling and also leave the bulk of “personal development” come parents, regional communities, and churches.

Finally, the biggest difference in between the era the the high school movement and our own time is the substantial increase in the variety of children comes from single-parent families. Also often, the response of education progressives has actually been—again, mirroring the response of their forebears—to reduced standards or to sell therapeutic or culturally “appropriate” curricula because that disadvantaged students. Here, again, the answer must be no to dispense v high standards but instead to find effective methods of imparting the indispensable expertise of math, language, science, and also humanities to students most in require of such learning. Part charter schools, which have actually experimented with much longer school days, rigorous discipline, and also other approaches, could allude the way in this respect.

See more: Is It A Sin To Eat Meat On Fridays, Why Don’T Catholics Eat Meat On Fridays

It would certainly be too much to intend that the unified States, in in search of answers come its present educational quandaries, will prevent mistakes such as the high school activity made. But if we also approximate that ingenuity and also success, us will carry out well.